“Just relax” rarely helps when you’re under pressure, because at that moment your body has a job: to be ready. An order to relax leaves that job in place and adds one more effort on top of it. That’s often why you can’t relax even when you try. Tension eases more easily when you get to know it, notice where it is and what it’s doing, and then show your body an easier way to be ready. Further down there’s also one question you can ask yourself whenever you feel yourself tightening.
“Just relax” is the easiest advice to give and the hardest to follow.
Giving it is simple. It’s two words, said in a second, and they sound caring. Following it is another matter, because nobody who says it tells you how.
When someone tells you to relax, or you tell yourself, your body is asked to let go of tension on command, whatever the reason the tension is there.
What happens when you order yourself to relax
Psychologist Daniel Wegner and his colleagues at the University of Virginia tested what happens when people try to relax under pressure [1]. Students solved simple word and number tasks. Some of them were told it was an intelligence test, so they were under pressure. The others did the same tasks without that pressure. In both groups, some students were told to relax completely, and the rest got no instruction at all. The whole time, the researchers measured how much the students’ skin was sweating, because sweating increases when the body is tense and on alert.
The result was the opposite of what you’d expect. Students who tried to relax while they believed they were being evaluated sweated more. Their bodies were more tense than those of students under the same pressure who hadn’t been told to relax. When there was no pressure, the instruction to relax didn’t calm them in any noticeable way.
Wegner explains it like this. While you’re trying to relax, part of your attention keeps checking whether the tension is still there. Under pressure, that checking is exactly what keeps the body alert, so the attempt to relax easily produces the opposite effect.
What matters for you is this: we usually tell ourselves to relax precisely when we’re under pressure, and that’s exactly when the order is most likely to backfire.
Two intentions in one body
Why would your body refuse something that so obviously feels good? Tension has many causes: a habit of how you hold yourself, tiredness, concentration, protecting a place that’s been hurt. When you’re under pressure, one more cause joins them. Your body now has two intentions at the same time. One wants calm, sleep, and ease. The other wants to be ready for whatever comes next.
That second intention shows up in the body: shoulders that rise before a difficult conversation, a belly that pulls in, a breath that stops halfway. To this intention, relaxing under pressure is irresponsible. When you tell it to relax, it hears “drop your guard right now.”
Psychologists have described this resistance to relaxing in research, too. As early as 1983, Frederick Heide and Thomas Borkovec noticed that in some people who worry a lot, tension rises during relaxation exercises instead of falling [2]. Michelle Newman of Pennsylvania State University and her team later linked this to a fear of a sudden shift from calm into worry [3].
For these people, relaxing feels risky. Once they relax, worry can arrive without warning, so the tension stays on as protection against that sudden drop.
Look, too, at who is speaking when you give yourself the order, say in bed at night before a hard day. The voice that orders you to relax often belongs to the same part of you that usually says “you have to get it all done” and “you can’t make a mistake.” That’s the inner critic, and it’s just as tense as the shoulders it’s talking to. Seen through parts work, this scene is one tense part shouting at another, and each of them is trying, in its own way, to keep you safe.
The paradox of change
In 1970, psychiatrist Arnold Beisser, who was close to Gestalt therapy, published a short essay that is still widely quoted, The Paradoxical Theory of Change [4]. His starting image is a person torn between who they think they should be and who they are. While they swing back and forth between the two, they fully belong to neither, and they stay stuck where they are.
Beisser’s thesis sounds like a riddle: change happens when a person becomes what they are. When they stop swinging and step fully into what is happening now, change starts on its own.
If you carry this over to the body, the first step toward relaxing looks unusual. You let the tension be there, just as it is, and you get to know it. Then you no longer have to talk it into leaving. You can notice where it is, how strong it is, and what it’s trying to do.
Parts with good intentions
A similar idea runs through an approach developed by the American psychotherapist Richard Schwartz. It’s called Internal Family Systems (IFS). The title of his 2021 book No Bad Parts sums it up [5]. Schwartz describes the inner world as a set of parts, and some of them act as protectors. They try to keep you from pain, even when the way they do it wears you out.
The critic, the part that’s always planning, and the part that tightens before every conversation can all be protectors of this kind. Schwartz suggests approaching them with curiosity.
IFS is a psychotherapy model. The idea of parts is also used in coaching, and that’s how I work with it. Parts work in my sessions is part of somatic coaching, where alongside the conversation we also follow what’s happening in the body. I don’t offer psychotherapy.
For this article, one idea from Schwartz’s approach is useful: you can look at tension as something that has an intention of its own. It’s a way of looking that makes the work easier. It doesn’t explain every kind of tension. Once you try it, you can replace the order to relax with a question.
How to relax without fighting yourself
You can see Beisser’s paradox in the body very concretely. When you try to force your shoulders down, you add a second effort to the first: some muscles keep lifting, and others now push down. Your shoulders may be lower, but there’s more effort than before. The same thing happens with a clenched jaw: when you force your teeth apart, a few minutes later your jaw finds its familiar position again.
Tension you attack defends itself. Tension you get to know can begin to change.
In Awareness Through Movement, Moshe Feldenkrais wrote that you start to sense finer differences only when you reduce the effort [6]. While you’re clenching with full force, you can’t notice how hard you’re clenching.
That’s why the movements in his lessons are small and slow. When the effort is smaller, something that was hidden until then becomes visible: how your shoulders rise, when your breath stops, how your weight moves onto your feet.
For tension that serves readiness, this is good news. The readiness can stay. It just needs less effort. In somatic work, we see good posture as the freedom to move in any direction. A body that isn’t clenched reacts faster, because it doesn’t have to let go of its grip before it can move.
When small, slow movements show you that your shoulders can be ready without tightening, the readiness stays and the effort goes down.
One question for your day
Instead of an exercise, here is one question:
What is this tension trying to do for me?
When to ask it. At the moment you catch yourself saying “just relax” to yourself. After a message that upsets you, before a conversation you’re worried about, in bed when sleep won’t come, or when someone else tells you to relax and you feel yourself tighten even more.
How. Ask the question quietly, to yourself, and wait a few breaths for the answer. Let the answer come from your body first, as a sensation or an image, and only then as words. It can be simple: “so nothing catches me off guard,” “so I can make it to the end of the day,” “so I don’t say something I’ll regret.” You don’t have to change anything. It’s enough to hear the answer.
Why a question. An order has only two outcomes, success or failure, so your attention keeps checking on it, just like the students in Wegner’s study. A question has no wrong answer, so there’s nothing to check. That way the tension becomes something you get to know.
Sometimes, after the answer, something small lets go: your out-breath gets longer, your shoulders drop a millimeter. If nothing changes, the tension may have another cause, such as tiredness, habit, or a long time sitting. Even then, it’s worth asking again tomorrow.
Where to go from here
- Online 1:1 sessions: online Feldenkrais sessions combine the Feldenkrais Method with the other somatic approaches I use, and we work on exactly what you need. From session to session I follow your progress and we build on it. It starts with a free 20-minute call.
- Workshops, live and online: all upcoming workshops and retreats are on the events page.
Frequently asked questions
Is muscle tension always bad?
No. Without muscle tension you couldn’t stand up, hold a cup, or turn your head. The trouble starts when tension stays after its job is done, for example when your shoulders are still up an hour after a hard conversation.
What is the inner critic?
It’s the inner voice that judges you, warns you, and hurries you along. From the point of view of parts work, the critic is a protector: it tries to save you from mistakes, shame, or rejection, even though it goes about it harshly.
What is Internal Family Systems (IFS)?
IFS is a psychotherapy model developed by Richard Schwartz. It starts from the idea that the personality is made up of several parts, each with its own role, and the aim is to relate to those parts with curiosity and understanding.
What is parts work?
It’s a way of working in which you see your inner voices and reactions as parts, each with its own intention and role. It’s used in psychotherapy and in coaching, and in a somatic approach, attention also goes to how each part feels in the body.
Can you do parts work on your own, without a therapist?
Yes, to a small degree. A single curious question to your tension or your critic already changes how you relate to them. For deeper work, it helps to have someone who guides you and notices what you miss.
How do you relax when someone tells you to relax?
Don’t try to relax right away. Notice where you’re tightening, most often in your jaw, shoulders, or belly, and bring your attention down to your feet, which are carrying you. When you don’t have to carry out someone else’s order, it’s easier for your body to find less effort on its own.
Sources
- Wegner D. M., Broome A., Blumberg S. J. (1997). Ironic effects of trying to relax under stress. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 35(1), 11 to 21.
- Heide F. J., Borkovec T. D. (1983). Relaxation-induced anxiety: Paradoxical anxiety enhancement due to relaxation training. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 51(2), 171 to 182.
- Kim H., Newman M. G. (2019). The paradox of relaxation training: Relaxation induced anxiety and mediation effects of negative contrast sensitivity in generalized anxiety disorder and major depressive disorder. Journal of Affective Disorders, 259, 271 to 278.
- Beisser A. (1970). The Paradoxical Theory of Change. In: Fagan J., Shepherd I. L. (Eds.), Gestalt Therapy Now. Science and Behavior Books.
- Schwartz R. C. (2021). No Bad Parts: Healing Trauma and Restoring Wholeness with the Internal Family Systems Model. Sounds True.
- Feldenkrais M. (1972). Awareness Through Movement. Harper & Row.

I am Nikola, a certified Feldenkrais practitioner and somatic coach, with about nine years of somatic work. Here I write about different approaches to the body: how to understand it better, how to learn new ways of using it, and how to build a more holistic relationship with your body and with life.
Ways to work with me
- 1:1 somatic sessions onlineindividual work, online
- Online Feldenkrais sessionsIndividual guidance through movement on Zoom
- Workshops and retreatsin person, in a group
Stay connected
Get notified about upcoming classes and offerings.
Join the quiet WhatsApp group for occasional announcements, or follow along on Instagram.